← PHIL 109

Introduction to Formal Reasoning and Decision Making

Juan Comesaña

This is a textbook to accompany Philosophy 109 at Rutgers New Brunswick. It is about the formal tools we use to model good reasoning and rational choice.

The book has three parts. Part I builds the language of propositional logic and uses it to model valid arguments. Part II introduces probability, first as a measure over the possibilities that truth-tables represent and then axiomatically, and uses it to model probabilistic arguments; it ends with Bayesianism and the problem of priors. Part III applies both to rational choice: decisions under ignorance and under risk, Newcomb’s problem, and games.

Many examples and exercises link to three interactive labs (the Logic Lab, the Probability Lab, and the Decisions & Games Lab), where you can step through the book’s own examples and practice on new ones. The solutions to the exercises are at the end of the book, and in the web edition each exercise has its solution.

I have borrowed extensively from teaching notes by Max Bialek, Brian Weatherson, and Jonathan Weisberg. I have also borrowed from Resnik’s Choices for chapter 10.

Each chapter has the solutions to its exercises, and “Try it” links that open the course labs on the book's own examples. The whole book is also available as a PDF.

Contents

Part I Logic

  1. The language of propositional logic
  2. Translations
  3. Arguments and validity

Part II Probability

  1. Measures and stochastic truth-tables
  2. Axioms, definitions, and theorems
  3. Bayesianism

Part III Decision and Game Theory

  1. Decisions under ignorance
  2. Decisions under risk
  3. Newcomb’s problem
  4. Games

The definitions, axioms and theorems of probability are collected on the formula sheet.

The exercises and examples link to the course labs.